LONG OR MEDIUM CAGE REAR DERAILLEUR?
Lee,
What is the difference in a med cage and long cage rear derailleur aside from the physical length? Where would you use the long as opposed to the med?
Thanks, Richard
Hey Richard.
No real difference other than the length of the cage. If you have three rings and a big cassette, you need a long cage to wrangle all that chain. To optimize shifting and minimize wayward chain syndrome (WCS), you want your chain as short as possible. You can roll a shorter chain if you’re rocking a single ring, a tighter cassette, and/or you really know how to shift.
I was just about to post this answer, then the obsessive compulsive part of me kicked in. So here we go:
| Derailleur | Capacity | What that means |
| Long cage XT | 45T | With 22,32,44 rings and 11-34 cassette, you can use any gear combo. Idiot proof, but lots of chain slap. |
| Med cage XT | 33T | In the small ring you can’t go any smaller than the 23t cog. Which is fine, because by then you should shift to the middle ring. Slightly better shifting and less WCS. |
I just installed a short cage SRAM X.9 on my Specialized SX. Short chain, clean shifting. Super tasty!
—Lee
5 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
Ben Says September 4, 2006 @ 11:30 pm
Those both say long cage???
MyEpic Says October 20, 2006 @ 9:15 pm
The 33T should say medium.
To figure out the how many “T”s you need, take the difference between the big ring and small ring and add that to the difference big cog and small cog of your cassette. For most mtb bikes it is (44-22) + (34-11) = 45. That’s how many teeth the rear derailleur needs to take up if you cross the chain.
If you follow the “rules” and don’t cross the chain (big ring, big cog or small ring, small cog) then a medium cage is good enough. But if you race (or are just lazy), you may want to cross the chain for short durations.
The shorter the derailleur cage, the less flex, crisper shifting. But you have to be more disciplined in your shifting otherwise you will have too much slack when you are on the small ring or bind up your chain when you are on the big ring.
If you go for medium, keep track of the gear indicator on you handle bars.
josh Says February 24, 2007 @ 4:44 am
hey up, was just reading this cause a friend of mine has an x.9 short cage going cheap, i am using one 36-tooth wheel on the front and a 11-32 8-speed casset on the back, will the short cage be compatable with this setup, cheers
leelikesbikes Says February 24, 2007 @ 9:07 am
OK.
Lee Likes Bikes Pingback November 30, 2007 @ 6:49 am
[...] read: Long or medium cage rear derailleur? This article talks about Shimano XT. November 30, 2007 : Posted In: Ask Lee, Equipment [...]